Butter SaltedvsFish Tilapia

Fish Tilapia has more protein, Fish Tilapia is lower in calories, while Fish Tilapia is leaner.

🎯When to Eat What

Goal-based picks for Butter Salted vs Fish Tilapia

⚖️Watching your weight

Go with Fish Tilapia at just 96 kcal per 100g — 87% fewer calories.

🫄Staying full longer

Fish Tilapia will keep you satisfied longer with 20.1g protein — fat and protein slow digestion while fiber adds bulk, keeping hunger at bay.

💪Building muscle

Fish Tilapia packs 20.1g of protein per 100g (84% of calories from protein) — the better pick for muscle growth and recovery.

❤️Heart health

Fish Tilapia is the heart-friendlier option with lower saturated fat, less sodium, more potassium.

🍌Electrolytes & cramp prevention

Fish Tilapia provides 302mg of potassium per 100g — important for muscle function, hydration, and blood pressure.

🏆Overall healthier choice

Fish Tilapia edges ahead overall with more protein, less saturated fat, more potassium — making it the more nutritious option for everyday eating.

🔥Calorie Breakdown

Butter Salted
717kcal
Protein0%
Carbs0%
Fat100%
Fish Tilapia
96kcal
Protein84%
Carbs0%
Fat16%

💪Macronutrient Comparison

Butter SaltedFish Tilapia
ProteinB Wins
0.85g
20g
CarbohydratesA Wins
<0.1g
0g
Total FatB Wins
81g
1.7g
Dietary Fiber
0g
0g

📊Full Nutrition Comparison

NutrientButter SaltedFish TilapiaDiff
💪Macronutrients
Calories717kcal36%96kcal5%+621kcal
Protein0.85g2%20g40%<0.1g
Total Fat81g104%1.7g2%+79g
Saturated Fat51g257%0.58g3%+51g
Trans Fat3.3g
Cholesterol215mg72%50mg17%+165mg
Carbohydrates<0.1g0%0g0%+<0.1g
Dietary Fiber0g0%0g0%
Sugars<0.1g0g+<0.1g
Vitamins
Vitamin A684mcg76%0mcg0%+684mcg
Vitamin C0mg0%0mg0%
Vitamin D0mcg0%3.1mcg16%<0.1mcg
Vitamin E2.3mg15%0.40mg3%+1.9mg
Vitamin K7.0mcg6%1.4mcg1%+5.6mcg
Vitamin B6<0.1mg0%0.16mg10%<0.1mg
Vitamin B120.17mcg7%1.6mcg66%<0.1mcg
Folate3.0mcg1%24mcg6%<0.1mcg
Thiamin (B1)<0.1mg0%<0.1mg3%<0.1mg
Riboflavin (B2)<0.1mg3%<0.1mg5%<0.1mg
Niacin (B3)<0.1mg0%3.9mg24%<0.1mg
🔶Minerals
Sodium643mg28%52mg2%+591mg
Calcium24mg2%10mg1%+14mg
Iron<0.1mg0%0.56mg3%<0.1mg
Potassium24mg1%302mg6%<0.1mg
Phosphorus24mg2%170mg14%<0.1mg
Magnesium2.0mg0%27mg6%<0.1mg
Zinc<0.1mg1%0.33mg3%<0.1mg
Copper0mg0%<0.1mg8%<0.1mg
Manganese0mg0%<0.1mg2%<0.1mg
Selenium1.0mcg2%42mcg76%<0.1mcg

🔬Nutritional Analysis

Calories: Fish Tilapia is significantly lower in calories at just 96 kcal per 100g compared to 717 kcal for Butter Salted — that's 647% fewer calories, making Fish Tilapia the better choice for calorie-conscious diets.

Protein: Fish Tilapia provides more protein with 20.1g versus 0.85g per 100g. In terms of protein-to-calorie efficiency, Fish Tilapia offers better value for building and maintaining muscle.

Fat: Fish Tilapia is the leaner option with 1.7g of total fat per 100g compared to 81.1g. Fish Tilapia has less saturated fat (0.585g vs 51.4g).

Key Vitamins: The most notable vitamin differences are in Vitamin A (Butter Salted: 684mcg vs 0mcg), Vitamin D (Fish Tilapia: 3.1mcg vs 0mcg), Niacin (B3) (Fish Tilapia: 3.9mg vs 0.042mg).

Key Minerals: Notable mineral differences include Copper (Fish Tilapia: 0.075mg vs 0mg), Manganese (Fish Tilapia: 0.037mg vs 0mg), Selenium (Fish Tilapia: 41.8mcg vs 1mcg).

Diet Suitability: Both fit a low-carb or keto diet. Fish Tilapia fits a high-protein diet. Fish Tilapia fits a low-fat diet. Fish Tilapia fits a low-sodium diet.

🔗Related Comparisons

Data from USDA FoodData Central. All values per 100g.